Jesus Muhammad-Ali painted a portrait of Louis Farrakhan, the leader of the Nation of Islam, in 1984. Ali sued The Final Call for copyright infringement in 2013. The Final Call is a newspaper that considers itself the “propagation arm of the Nation of Islam.” Although The Final Call admitted to selling over one hundred copies of Ali’s portrait of Farrakhan, the district court ruled in favor of The Final Call.
On appeal to the Seventh Circuit, Ali argued that “the district court misstated the elements of a prima facie copyright infringement claim and erroneously shifted to him the burden of proving that the copies were unauthorized. Ali is correct, and The Final Call proved no defense. We therefore reverse. (Opinion pdf page 2).